• 2 Posts
  • 10 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: October 23rd, 2023

help-circle



  • Alright I think I know what you mean, but I’m still not sure we’re actually on the same page regarding encryption.

    If a company is forced to do whatever ths government commands it to do, that’s only valid within certain constraints.

    For example, the company cannot be forced to grow wings snd fly to thr heavens. That’s physically impossible.

    Similarly, it also cannot provide the decrypted messages of its users because it (like Signal) does not have the KEYS that are absolutely 100% necessary for decrypting the encrypted messages of its users. So, again, it’s physically impossible to hand over either the keys or the decrypted messages.

    However, there is one remedy that Signal CAN do, if somehow forced. That’s changing the Signal program. It certainly can push an update that sends Signal the keys for decryption.

    However, at that point, the source code at github doesn’t match the compiled binary of the program anymore, and very good chance people would notice, and thereby people would lose trust in Signal.

    I’m not sure about the examples you gave about the government being successful in obtaining user details of a company. Were those details encrypted as well? Was the source code publically available? Was the program popular?